Over 10 years we help companies reach their financial and branding goals. Engitech is a values-driven technology agency dedicated.



411 University St, Seattle, USA


+1 -800-456-478-23

Web Application Security Testing
types of penetration testing

Black-box vs. Grey-box vs. White-box: Which Penetration Test Is Right for You?

You need to know if your company’s security controls and defenses can withstand a real cyber attack. Penetration testing is how you find out, but with three main types, black-box, grey-box, and white-box, how do you choose? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Penetration tests can sound intimidating, but it’s one of the best ways to identify vulnerabilities before the bad guys do. Whether you want to simulate an outside hacker with no knowledge (black-box), a hacker with partial inside knowledge (grey-box), or a test with full access (white-box), one of these penetration test methods will fit your needs. You’ll gain valuable insights into weaknesses in your systems and ways to address them. Sleep better at night knowing your data and applications have been battle-tested. 

Let’s take a closer look at each penetration test approach so you can determine the right level of visibility and rigor for your organization. Knowledge is power, so power up and let’s get started 🙂

difference between black box grey box and white box testing

Black-box Penetration Testing: Testing From an Outside Perspective

Want to see how vulnerable your systems really are to outside attackers? black-box penetration testing is for you! With this approach, testers act as external hackers to simulate a cyber attack on your network and see what damage could be done.

As an enthusiastic business owner concerned about security, black-box testing is a great choice. Most penetration testers get a thrill out of the challenge of breaking into your system without any inside knowledge, and you get peace of mind knowing your defenses can withstand threats from the outside such as financially motivated threat actors or nation-state threat actors. It’s a win-win!

The penetration testers generally start at square one, doing reconnaissance to gather publicly available information about your company to help plan their digital infiltration. They scan for open ports, guess passwords, and analyze third-party software for weaknesses – using all the latest tools and techniques real hackers would employ.

When the test is complete, you’ll receive an exciting report detailing any vulnerabilities found and how to patch them up quickly. You can then make changes to strengthen firewalls, update software, improve passwords, and monitor for future threats. Think of it as an entertaining security audit!

Why wait to see if you can survive an actual cyber attack? Get black-box testing today and put your systems to the ultimate test. Your IT team and customers will thank you for taking action now to protect data and infrastructure from the types of threats that are becoming more common every day. Stay one step ahead of the hackers – you’ll be glad you did!

Grey-box Penetration Testing: Gaining Limited Internal Knowledge

Looking for the perfect level of penetration test insight? grey-box penetration testing could be just the solution for you! With grey-box testing, you provide the penetration test team with limited internal network access, allowing them to dive a bit deeper into your systems.

This approach is ideal if you want more vulnerability coverage than a black-box test but aren’t quite ready to expose all your digital secrets. The penetration testers gain access to things like roles, IP addresses, and server names but not full admin access. They’ll have an easier time mimicking real hacker behavior and spotting weaknesses that could lead to data breaches or system takeovers.

Compared to black-box testing where penetration testers go in blind, grey-box penetration tests are likely to uncover more critical risks and provide more comprehensive remediation reports. Your team receives actionable recommendations for closing security holes before cybercriminals discover and exploit them. Grey-box testing is a good choice against insider threat actors who does not have full access to the system and infrastructure. 

Worried about internal access compromising sensitive data or systems? Don’t be! Reputable penetration test firms follow strict confidentiality practices and only access information relevant to the agreed-upon scope. They have no interest in stealing or modifying your data – only helping you strengthen your security posture.

If you want maximum vulnerability visibility without a full internal reveal, grey-box penetration testing is the perfect choice. You’ll gain a wealth of insights to fortify your digital defenses while maintaining control over how much access is granted.

White-box Penetration Testing: Full Transparency Testing

Full Disclosure

With a white-box penetration test, you’re giving the ethical hackers the keys to the kingdom—full access to your systems and networks. This transparent approach allows them to fully analyze your infrastructure from the inside out to uncover vulnerabilities you never even knew existed and maybe would not find with black-box or grey-box penetration testing.

  • They’ll scour your systems with a fine-toothed comb, poking and prodding to find any weak spots or faults in your security defenses.
  • With privileged insider access, white-box testing will be extremely thorough. Penetration testers can scrutinize everything from your servers and network equipment to individual workstations and IoT devices.

Comprehensive Results

A white-box assessment will provide the most in-depth findings and recommendations to bolster your security. The testers will generate a robust report detailing each vulnerability discovered, how it can be exploited, and specific fixes to resolve the issues. They’ll also suggest long-term strategies to strengthen your overall cybersecurity posture.

  • You’ll gain invaluable insights from their “behind-the-scenes” vantage point and a roadmap for hardening your digital environment against real-world insider threats.
  • The transparency of a white-box test builds trust in the client-tester relationship and a shared understanding of your unique risks and priorities.

Maximizing Value

For many organizations, the benefits of a comprehensive white-box test far outweigh any temporary discomfort with granting such broad access. The more visibility and control you give the testers, the more value you’ll get from their work.

A white-box penetration test is ideal if you want to identify as many security flaws as possible and get expert guidance on how to systematically reduce vulnerabilities in your digital infrastructure. While it requires trust to let ethical hackers roam freely in your systems, the rewards of such radical transparency can be very good. A single test could uncover hidden threats and help you avoid a disastrous cyber attack!

Traitors!, Thrill seekers! , Hacktivists! , and Money Seekers!: Who should you be careful against?

Before we continue, let’s talk about threat actors first. This might sound irrelevant at first but how are you planning to choose a penetration test type if you do not even know who you want to be safe against?

There are 5 main types of threat actors; Insider threat actors which can count as traitors, Thrill seekers who evolved into modern trolls nowadays, Hacktivists cyber activists as the name suggests, Nation-state threat actors who generally governmental intelligence agencies or some professional cyber criminal organizations that worked with nations, and finally Financially Motivated threat actors who have the sole ambition of earning money by selling victim companies info or via ransomware.

threat actors

I am going to explain these threat actors one-by-one while giving general recommendations on which threat actor targets which type of organization. After that threat actors will be an important factor in deciding which one to choose; black-box, white-box, or grey-box.

Financially Motivated Threat Actors

The most common type of threat actors are individuals driven by financial motives. They seek profit and often focus on organizations that possess sensitive financial data.

  • If you are concerned about financially motivated actors, then a black-box pentest may be the best option. These actors are unlikely to have any inside knowledge of your organization compared to other threat actors, so a black-box test will simulate an attack from an external threat actor.

Nation-state Supported Threat Actors

Nation-state actors, on the other hand, are threat actors who receive support from governments. They exhibit high levels of sophistication and are capable of targeting organizations with critical infrastructure or valuable information.

  • If you are concerned about nation-state actors, then a white-box pentest may be the best option. These actors are often highly sophisticated and may have access to some of your organization’s internal information. A white-box test will allow the tester to simulate an attack from an insider threat actor.

Hacktivists and Thrill Seekers 

Hacktivists, as another category of threat actors, derive their motivation from political or social ideologies. They may direct their attention towards organizations they disagree with or believe to be promoting opposing ideologies.

Thrill seekers and trolls represent a different kind of threat actor group, motivated by the thrill or attention they gain from their actions. They may target organizations for no other reason than to see if they can get away with it.

  • If you are concerned about hacktivists or thrill seekers, then a grey-box pentest may be the best option. These actors are less likely to have the same level of sophistication as nation-state actors, so a grey-box test may be sufficient to identify and fix any vulnerabilities that they could exploit.

Insider Threat Actors

Lastly, insiders are threat actors who possess legitimate access to an organization’s systems. They are often the most dangerous threat actors because they have the knowledge and the ability to cause the most damage.

White-box penetration test is a better option than a grey-box penetration test for protecting against insider threat actors if the organization is willing to share the source code and configuration files with the pentester. This is because the pentester will have complete knowledge of the target system, which will allow them to identify and exploit any vulnerabilities that could be exploited by an insider threat actor.

If the organization is not willing to share the source code and configuration files with the pentester, then a grey-box pentest is the best option. This is because a grey-box pentest will still allow the pentester to identify and exploit vulnerabilities that could be exploited by an insider threat actor, but it will be less expensive, and less time-consuming than a white-box pentest.

penetration testing methods table

When Is Black-box Penetration Testing the Right Choice?

black box testing

When is black-box penetration testing the right choice for you? If you want to simulate a real-world attack, black-box testing is the way to go. This type of penetration test provides the most realistic results because ethical hackers have limited knowledge about your system.

Maximum Realism

Black-box testing provides the most authentic penetration test experience. The penetration testers only have access to information that an actual malicious hacker would, like your company’s website and public-facing servers except you are considering insider threats as threat actors. They have to find vulnerabilities and exploit them just like a real criminal hacker would. This helps identify weak spots in your security posture that could be abused by unauthorized individuals.

Unbiased Assessment

With no prior knowledge of your infrastructure or security measures, black-box tests provide an impartial evaluation of your cyber defenses. Penetration testers who conduct black-box penetration tests don’t make any assumptions based on previous tests or inside information. Each penetration test is approached with a fresh perspective.

Challenging But Effective

Black-box penetration tests can be more difficult and time-consuming since ethical hackers have limited visibility. However, the results provide an authentic assessment of your security strengths and weaknesses. If vulnerabilities are detected, you receive a legitimate report of the issues that must be addressed to bolster your cyber defenses. 

Why Choose Grey-box or White-box Penetration Testing Over Black-Box?

Why choose grey-box or white-box penetration testing? Because you want the fullest, most comprehensive evaluation of your system’s security or just more coverage than real-world scenarios to see more vulnerabilities. These more invasive methods will uncover vulnerabilities that basic black-box tests simply can’t detect.

See Your Defenses in Action

With grey-box or white-box testing, your penetration testers have access to information like network diagrams, source code, and admin credentials. This allows them to analyze how your security controls and defenses actually function when faced with an attack. They can spot gaps, weaknesses, or misconfigurations in your system that wouldn’t be apparent otherwise.

Simulate Realistic Threat Actors, Traitors!!

Advanced hackers often have insider information they’ve stolen or pieced together. Grey-box and white-box testing replicate these more sophisticated adversaries to strengthen your security against the latest threats. The penetration testers should have a wider range of tools and techniques at their disposal to imitate how real-world actors target systems with insider information.

Fix Deeper Issues

When penetration testers have greater visibility into your infrastructure, they can uncover more critical risks and the root causes behind them. Rather than just identifying surface-level vulnerabilities, they can trace problems back to their source in coding errors, design flaws, or faulty architecture. You’ll receive tailored recommendations for comprehensive, long-term solutions to shore up your security at its foundations.

In summary, choosing a higher-level penetration test like a grey-box or a white-box will provide you with key insights into how well your security controls actually function and how they stand up to advanced adversaries. While more intensive, the results can be invaluable in building robust, in-depth defenses for your digital assets. The extra investment is well worth the peace of mind.

Gray-box or White-box, Are They Similar?

Since grey-box and white-box penetration tests are similar to each other, we covered them together. But of course, there are differences between them as we mentioned above. Here are some brief characteristics of these two penetration testing methods:

  • Grey-box testing shares details about your network architecture and IP addresses, allowing penetration testers to probe for vulnerabilities more efficiently. They can focus their efforts on the areas that would be most appealing to hackers. 
  • White-box testing provides penetration testers administrative access to your systems and network devices. With full visibility into your infrastructure, the white-box penetration test delivers the most comprehensive evaluation of how susceptible you are to cyber threats. Testers have access to sensitive data and can test for vulnerabilities in a way that realistically simulates an insider attack.

How to Choose a Good Consultancy Firm

how to choose penetration testing company

Do Your Homework

The penetration test industry can be tricky to navigate, so make sure you do some digging to find a reputable firm. Check reviews from real clients to get a sense of their experience. See what certifications they hold. Also, see do they have any advisories, and if they how much and what type of advisories they have. These show they have proven skills and stay up-to-date with the latest penetration test techniques.

Experience Matters

Look for a consultancy firm with several years of experience specifically in penetration test. An ideal firm will have conducted hundreds of penetration tests across many industries. They’ll have encountered diverse systems and infrastructures, allowing them to handle any challenge. Experience also means they can work efficiently without excessive on-the-job learning. The last thing you want is a novice penetration tester fumbling around your network 😀

Swift and Smooth Communication Before Seal the Deal

When choosing a penetration testing consultancy, don’t overlook the important communication aspects before sealing the deal. The ability to communicate swiftly and accurately during the contract phase says a lot about a company’s professionalism and dedication to customer satisfaction. Look for quick responses to questions, and detailed descriptions tailored to your needs.

Meet the Team

The penetration testers themselves are the most crucial part of any consultancy. Ask to meet with the team who will work on your test. Look for highly skilled, professionally certified penetration testers who stay passionate about their craft. Their enthusiasm will shine through in the quality of work they produce. Strong soft skills are also important, as they’ll need to present findings to your team in a constructive, solutions-focused way.

Read Reviews and Case Studies

Do some research online to find reviews and ratings of different firms. Look for companies with mostly positive reviews mentioning things like actionable reports, reasonable pricing, and overall quality service. Also, check if the company provides case studies on past penetration test projects. This will give you an idea of their general process and deliverables. If they don’t share case studies due to confidentiality, they should at least be willing to provide references from past clients.

Stay Within Budget

Penetration testing services span a range of fees depending on the size and scope of work. However, a good consultancy will always provide transparency around their pricing and work within your budget. They can help determine the optimal level of testing needed to gain useful insights into your security posture without breaking the bank.

Trust Your Gut

Finally, go with a firm you feel comfortable with and confident in. Schedule calls to interview consultants, discuss the project, and determine if you feel at ease with their team and process. Your penetration test partner will have deep access to your systems, so you want to choose a company you can trust completely. If anything feels off, keep looking. The right firm for you is out there!

By evaluating experience, skills, passion, communication, and budget-friendliness, you’ll find a penetration test firm poised to provide maximum value. With the right partner, you’ll gain priceless peace of mind knowing your critical assets and infrastructure are protected from cyber threats. Choose wisely!

Everybody Loves Bullet Points in Articles

The choice between black-box, grey-box, and white-box testing depends on several factors, including the testing objectives, the level of access to the application, threat actors, and the testing resources available. Here are some bullet points for busy readers to see the differences 🙂

Black-box Testing:

  • Consider black-box testing if you trust your employees and want to perform the most realistic penetration test.
  • Black-box penetration tests can be more time-consuming to achieve the same vulnerabilities compared to grey-box and white-box testing but in the end, you will have a better understanding of your security posture.
  • Good to use against Financially Motivated Threat Actors.

Grey-box Testing:

  • Consider grey-box testing when you want to give intermediate knowledge of the internal workings of the application to penetration tester, but not complete access to the source code.
  • Grey-box testing is well-suited for web application security testing, as it considers both the high-level design environment and inter-operability conditions.
  • This approach allows for better variety and depth in test cases compared to black-box testing.
  • Grey-box testing techniques can help uncover potential vulnerabilities and issues that may not be apparent in black-box testing.
  • Good to use against Hacktivists and Thrill Seekers.

White-box Testing:

  • Opt for white-box testing when you can have complete knowledge of the internal data structures, logic flow, and source code.
  • White-box testing provides the most comprehensive coverage and allows for in-depth analysis of the application’s internals.
  • This approach is suitable for algorithm testing and when a high level of code accuracy is required.
  • White-box testing is typically performed by penetration testers and developers who have a deep understanding of the codebase.
  • Good to use against Nation-state Supported Threat Actors, and Insider Threat Actors.


So there you have, three types of penetration tests to choose from, each with its pros and cons. At the end of the day, you need to go with what’s right for your organization and testing objectives. Want to simulate an outside attack with limited internal knowledge? Black-box is the way to go. Need to validate internal controls and policies? Choose white-box. Unsure and want the best of both worlds? grey-box penetration test has you covered. The most important thing is taking that crucial first step to assess your cyber risk. Don’t delay, start evaluating your options today and get scheduled for a penetration test. Staying on top of security and compliance has never been more critical. Any penetration test is better than none, and you’ll gain valuable insights into strengthening your security posture regardless of which method you select. The threats are out there, but with the right penetration test partner or consultancy firm by your side helping you uncover weaknesses before the bad actors do, you can rest assured you’re doing everything possible to lock them out. So take a deep breath and dive in!

Let’s talk about conducting cybersecurity research of your web application.

Book a chat with a cybersecurity expert

    Is this article helpful to you? Share it with your friends.


    Ulaş Deniz İlhan